Despite the Beat, Q4 GDP Conceals Slowing Economic Momentum
At first glance, this week's GDP report revealed that the U.S. economy expanded at an above-trend pace in the fourth quarter. Underlying details, however, were less encouraging than the stronger-than-expected headline gain. When combined with the waning performance of recently monthly data, the Q4 GDP report suggests that the U.S. economy ended last year with a distinct loss of momentum that is likely to carry through into 2023.
Real GDP expanded at an annualized pace of 2.9% in the fourth quarter relative to the third quarter. This marks the second straight quarter of above-trend growth, as real GDP increased at a 3.2% pace in Q3. On a year-over-year basis, however, real GDP growth moderated to a 1.0% pace, down substantially from the 5.7% rate registered in Q4 2021.
The composition of fourth quarter growth was not nearly as strong as the headline figure would suggest. As businesses added nearly $130 billion to their stocks, the inventory build contributed a stronger-than-expected 1.5 percentage points to top-line growth, reflecting, in part, strength in manufacturing, mining and utilities. We are mindful that this inventory build could be unintended and, therefore, presents downside risk in Q1. Another surprise was net exports, which added 0.6 percentage points to headline GDP. Exports fell 1.3% reflecting deteriorating external demand, while imports declined 4.6% amid the ongoing deterioration in domestic demand for goods from abroad. Government outlays registered another solid performance in Q4, up 3.7%, with gains in both federal and local spending.
A better measure of underlying demand is real final sales to private domestic purchasers. Comprised of consumer spending and business fixed investment, this component represents the core part of the economy that is targeted by monetary policy. Real personal consumption expenditures increased at a healthy 2.1% annualized pace, with the strongest gains coming in services. Spending on "other" services (notably international travel), restaurant dining and health care led the way, suggesting consumers are not done yet making up for experiences held off during the pandemic. Unfortunately, consumer spending's pace was front-loaded in the quarter and does not truly reflect the underlying trend. On a monthly basis, real consumer spending contracted in December (-0.3%) and November (-0.2%), following a solid gain in October (0.4%) (chart). This weakening performance suggests that higher interest rates are taking a bigger toll on the all-important U.S. consumer. Moreover, the weakness exhibited at the end of 2022 places consumer spending growth on an uphill battle in Q1.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Jul 13, 2021
We added 850,00 jobs in June, but much of that was State governments school districts in some parts of the Country reopening just in time for summer break.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Oct 14, 2020
The global mobility playing field is equalizing. Major European countries such as Germany and France have seen a slowdown in recent weeks, leaving them right in line with the United States relative to the January baseline.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Jun 13, 2020
Lock downs began to be lifted across most of the country by the end of May and the total amount of daily new coronavirus cases has been trending lower. But the flattening case count has not been consistent across the country.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Apr 04, 2020
Efforts to contain the virus are leading to millions of job losses and it’s likely only a matter of time before a majority of economic data reveal unprecedented declines.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Nov 24, 2020
The international economic news over the past week has been somewhat mixed. On the positive side, China’s October data showed ongoing growth in manufacturing and firming retail and service sector activity.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Jun 14, 2023
An unexpected spike in jobless claims is a sign that cracks are forming in the labor market. Higher mortgage rates look to be hindering a housing market rebound.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / May 17, 2023
In April, the CPI rose 0.4% on both a headline and core basis, keeping the core running at a 5.1% three-month annualized rate. However, details pointed to price growth easing ahead.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Jun 08, 2022
While talk of recession has kicked up in recent weeks, the majority of economic data remain consistent with modest growth.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / May 29, 2022
U.S. retail sales topped expectations in April, while industrial production also grew more rapidly than economists expected. Data on housing starts, home sales and homebuilder sentiment, however, showed tentative signs of cooling.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / May 25, 2020
The re-opening of the country is getting underway, with all 50 states starting to roll back restrictions.