Rock Solid Labor Market Keeps the Fed in a Hard Place
The month of May is off to a roaring start this week. On Monday, Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen warned that debt ceiling constraints could cause the U.S. Treasury to no longer be able to meet all of its obligations by early June. For further analysis on the debt ceiling issue, please see the Topic of the Week. The Federal Reserve's battle against inflation amid new banking sector volatility was another focus of attention. As widely expected, the FOMC raised the federal funds target range by 25 bps on Wednesday. The main takeaway, however, was that the hike could be the last of this tightening cycle. More detail on the outcome of the May 3rd FOMC meeting can be found in the Interest Rate Watch section below.
In addition to new fiscal and monetary policy guidance, a deluge of economic indicators were published this week. The state of the labor market was front and center. Employers added 253K jobs during April, easily besting the market consensus. Downward revisions to payroll gains in February and March spoiled some of April's upside surprise. That said, employers still added an average 285K net new jobs in the first four months of 2023, which reflects a more moderate but still-solid pace of hiring. The household survey also provided further evidence of a resilient labor market. Notably, the unemployment rate fell to 3.4% during the month, matching a 53-year low. After rising in each of the past four months, the labor force participation rate was essentially unchanged in April. Wage growth came in on the high-side, with average hourly earnings rising 0.5% during the month. While eyecatching, average hourly earnings growth now appears to be more in-line with other wage measures such as the Atlanta Fed Wage Tracker and the Employment Cost Index, both of which are still show a fairly strong pace of wage growth.
While the labor market appears to be rock solid at present, we still expect some cracks to form in coming months. Demand for labor clearly is cooling. While job openings remain elevated compared to pre-pandemic norms, the count of vacancies continues to trend lower and fell to 9.6 million in March, the lowest level since April 2021. So far in 2023, jobless claims have shifted slightly higher from the relatively low levels averaged last year, indicating an increased pace of layoffs. Most recently, initial claims rose to 242K in the last week of April.
The resiliency of the labor market illustrates one of the major challenges facing the Federal Reserve. Inflation has moderated, but still remains well above the Fed's 2% target. Price pressures easing without a material deterioration in job growth is an encouraging sign that the labor market is moving back into balance. That said, the path back to 2% inflation still looks like it will be a gradual process. Weak productivity growth is just one potential hurdle. Nonfarm labor productivity fell at a 2.7% annualized rate in Q1-2023, a quarterly decline that amounts to a 0.9% yearly drop. Unit labor costs picked up to a 6.3% annualized pace during the quarter. The challenge with weak productivity growth is that it could keep the pressure on labor costs, which now appear to be a driving force behind elevated service sector inflation.
One reason why service sector prices have yet to follow the same trajectory as goods prices is that demand for services has remained relatively buoyant. The ISM services index edged further into expansion territory in April, rising to 51.9 during the month. The slight improvement in the headline masked differences between current and future activity. The business activity index fell sharply during April, while the forward-looking new orders component rose markedly. Furthermore, underlying inflation pressures in the service sector have yet to fully die down, with the prices paid index inching higher during April. A similar trend was evident in the ISM manufacturing index for April. The headline manufacturing index rose to 47.1 in April, a slight gain which reflects a modest improvement in factory sector activity. The prices paid component, however, jumped up by four points and rose for the third time in four months. The upturn in prices paid suggests a growing share of surveyed producers are experiencing higher input prices.
Another potential test for the Fed will be navigating structural shifts in the economy which could prove unflinching to higher interest rates or cyclical fluctuations. Construction spending rose 0.3% during March. The monthly gain in total spending was driven almost entirely by another uptick in the nonresidential category. Manufacturing projects have been a significant driver of nonresidential outlays recently, and momentum does not appear to be slowing. During March, manufacturing outlays were over 62% above the pace registered in the same month last year. The remarkable rise largely reflects the build-out of electric vehicle production supply chains as well as new semiconductor manufacturing facilities. These structural shifts are likely to support activity as macroeconomic uncertainty, higher financing costs and tighter lending standards weigh on overall construction moving forward.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Aug 11, 2021
Despite a few misses on the headline numbers, economic data this week highlighted a theme of demand continuing to outstrip supply and ongoing slack in the labor market.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Jun 08, 2022
While talk of recession has kicked up in recent weeks, the majority of economic data remain consistent with modest growth.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Nov 28, 2019
A series of U.K. general election polls released this week continue to show Boris Johnson’s Conservative Party with a significant lead over the opposition Labor Party.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Aug 30, 2021
In other economic news, output continues to ramp up across the U.S., even as the resurgence in COVID cases is leading to some pullback in consumer engagement.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Oct 24, 2020
A recent strong report from the National Association of Homebuilders set the tone for another round of strong housing data. The NAHB index rose two points to a record high 85.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Sep 10, 2022
The ISM services index came in stronger than expected, and the underlying details pointed to service sector resilience with business activity and new orders notching their highest reading this year.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Oct 19, 2019
Personal consumption is still on track for a solid Q3, but retail sales declined in September for the first time in seven months.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Aug 09, 2023
Employment growth was broad-based, though reliant on a 87K gain in health care & social assistance. Modest gains from construction, financial activities and hospitality also contributed to private sector job growth.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Jan 19, 2021
The U.S. economy appears to be losing some momentum as the calendar turns to 2021 and the public health situation continues to deteriorate.
Wells Fargo Economics & Financial Report / Jun 22, 2020
Retail sales kicked off the week with a bang, rising 17.7% month-over-month in May. The increase was larger than every single one of the 74 forecast submissions.